Common FSBO Closing Mistakes in Illinois (And How We Prevent Them)

Selling a home without a real estate agent—commonly referred to as “For Sale By Owner” (FSBO)—can be empowering, profitable, and completely legal in Illinois. However, the closing process, which is the final and most legally intensive part of the sale, is where many FSBO sellers make critical errors. At The Real Estate Law Firm, we’ve helped hundreds of homeowners successfully navigate FSBO closings in Illinois, and we know exactly where these deals often go wrong—and how to stop those mistakes before they happen.

Explore our FSBO legal services today.

 FSBO Closing Mistakes

1. Incomplete or Improper Purchase Agreements

Mistake: One of the most common FSBO pitfalls is relying on a generic or incomplete purchase agreement. These documents often omit key terms like earnest money details, contingencies, or deadlines.

How We Prevent It: The Real Estate Law Firm drafts or reviews every FSBO purchase agreement to ensure it complies with Illinois law and clearly outlines all necessary terms. This protects both parties and significantly reduces the risk of post-contract disputes.

2. Failing to Provide Required Disclosures

Mistake: Illinois law requires sellers to provide a Residential Real Property Disclosure Report, Lead-Based Paint Disclosure (for homes built before 1978), and other relevant disclosures. FSBO sellers often forget or misunderstand these requirements.

How We Prevent It: Our legal team provides a checklist of all required disclosures and prepares the correct documentation to ensure full compliance with state and federal laws—protecting you from liability and potential lawsuits.

3. Title Issues Discovered Too Late

Mistake: Title problems like liens, unpaid taxes, or boundary disputes are often discovered at the eleventh hour, delaying or killing the deal.

How We Prevent It: The Real Estate Law Firm performs a preliminary title search early in the process. We identify and resolve any title issues before closing, ensuring a clean transfer of ownership and avoiding last-minute surprises.

4. Skipping Attorney Review

Mistake: Illinois is an attorney review state. FSBO sellers who don't retain an attorney during this critical window risk agreeing to unfavorable terms or being blindsided by buyer requests.

How We Prevent It: We engage in attorney review immediately after contract acceptance, making necessary modifications to protect your interests while ensuring compliance with the Illinois Residential Real Property Disclosure Act and other statutes.

5. Mishandling Earnest Money

Mistake: FSBO sellers may not know how to properly handle earnest money deposits. Keeping funds in personal accounts or failing to document them correctly can lead to serious legal trouble.

How We Prevent It: We coordinate with neutral third-party escrow agents to hold earnest money securely. We also document and track its handling properly in accordance with Illinois law.

6. Incorrect Proration of Taxes and Utilities

Mistake: Illinois property taxes are paid in arrears. Sellers often forget to properly prorate taxes, water bills, or association dues at closing.

How We Prevent It: The Real Estate Law Firm calculates and verifies all prorations to ensure a fair and accurate settlement statement. We confirm the buyer isn’t overpaying—and you aren’t leaving money on the table.

7. Overlooking Final Walkthrough Obligations

Mistake: Sellers may not understand that buyers have the right to conduct a final walk through before closing. If the home isn’t in the agreed condition, it can delay or derail the transaction.

How We Prevent It: We ensure sellers are prepared for the walkthrough and address any repair agreements in writing. Our attorneys are on standby to negotiate last-minute concerns if needed.

8. Missed Deadlines or Forgotten Contingencies

Mistake: FSBO deals frequently fall apart due to missed deadlines—financing, inspection, or appraisal contingencies are overlooked or not enforced.

How We Prevent It: We keep a shared closing timeline and actively monitor all contingency periods. Our team alerts you before critical deadlines and steps in to resolve issues proactively.

9. Not Preparing for a Smooth Closing Day

Mistake: FSBO sellers may show up to closing without the correct documents or identification. In some cases, they don’t even know where to go or what’s expected.

How We Prevent It: We handle all closing coordination—confirming the date, location, and required documents. We also attend the closing on your behalf if needed, ensuring every "i" is dotted and "t" is crossed.

10. Going It Alone Without Legal Guidance

Mistake: The biggest mistake is not hiring an attorney at all. In Illinois, real estate attorneys are not just helpful—they are essential, especially in FSBO transactions.

How We Prevent It: With The Real Estate Law Firm by your side, you get professional legal representation from contract to close. We ensure your transaction is legally sound, financially secure, and emotionally stress-free.

Meet our expert FSBO legal team.

Why Choose The Real Estate Law Firm for Your FSBO Closing?

At The Real Estate Law Firm, we understand the risks and rewards of selling your home without a realtor. Our attorneys are deeply experienced in Illinois FSBO transactions, offering flat-fee services that are cost-effective and comprehensive. Whether you're selling a condo in Chicago or a single-family home in Naperville, we’ll walk you through every step of the process—and prevent the mistakes that can cost you thousands.

Contact us for FSBO closing support.

FAQs

1. Is it legal to sell my home without a real estate agent in Illinois? 

Yes, FSBO is completely legal in Illinois, but sellers are still expected to follow all real estate laws, including proper disclosures and contracts.

2. Do I really need an attorney for an FSBO sale? 

While not legally required, having an attorney is highly recommended—and in Illinois, it’s customary and often essential for a successful FSBO closing.

3. How much does The Real Estate Law Firm charge for FSBO closings? 

We offer competitive flat-rate pricing for FSBO representation. Contact us for a personalized quote based on your property type and location.

4. What is the attorney review period in Illinois? 

Typically, it's five business days from the date of contract acceptance. During this time, attorneys can propose modifications or cancel the deal.

5. What disclosures am I required to provide? 

You must provide a Residential Real Property Disclosure, Lead-Based Paint Disclosure (if applicable), and potentially a Radon Disclosure, depending on your location.

6. How is earnest money handled in a FSBO transaction? 

It should be held by a neutral third party—often a title company or attorney—and documented properly in the purchase agreement.

7. Who prepares the closing documents in an FSBO sale? 

The Real Estate Law Firm handles all document preparation, including the deed, affidavit of title, bill of sale, and the closing statement.

8. What happens if the buyer wants repairs after the inspection? 

We negotiate on your behalf during the attorney review period to resolve repair requests fairly and legally.

9. Can you help resolve title issues before closing? 

Yes. We conduct early title searches and coordinate with title companies to fix issues like liens or boundary disputes well before closing day.

10. What should I bring to the closing? 

Typically, you’ll need government-issued ID, keys/garage remotes, and any agreed repair receipts. We’ll send a complete checklist before closing.